• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Bitterroot Star

Bitterroot Valley's best source for local news!

  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Classifieds
    • Buildings
    • Farm & Garden
    • For Rent
    • For Sale
    • Free
    • Help Wanted
    • Real Estate
    • Sales/Auctions
    • Services
  • Legal Notices
  • Obituaries
  • Calendar
  • Services
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Place Classified Ad
    • Submit a Press Release
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
  • Subscribe

Closed primary bad idea

October 2, 2014 by Guest Post

 

The Ravalli County Republican Central Committee has become part of a lawsuit to “close” the Republican primary; i.e., exclude voters who are not Republicans. This disenfranchises independents and others who wish to weigh in on which candidates make it to the general election. Montanans are independent people who historically vote for the person, not the party, and resent having party insiders limit their choices. The legislature has consistently refused to “close” primaries when extremists in both parties tried to do so.

These are the same type of people who a few years ago created at the Republican Party’s state convention a party “caucus” that would pick our presidential nominee for President. The caucus’ choice could override the voters in the Republican primary. That effort, and this one about closed primaries, are about insiders wishing to control the party and dilute the influence of the people. Empowering the party is their concern, not empowering the voters, not the good of the State of Montana. This thinking has resulted in a dysfunctional Congress, and for that matter, Montana Legislature.

I find it amusing that people who chide the courts for interfering with elected legislatures when those courts make the law (and do not simply interpret the law) are using those same courts to accomplish what they say they are against. If they cannot win an election, or a vote in the Montana legislature, they go to a federal court with an appointed judge.

Our Central Committee gave us Treasurer Valerie Stamey (fired with pay), Commissioner Susy Foss (14% of the primary vote), and Ron Stoltz (27% of the primary vote). Do we really want them to have more power?

I suggest that these controlling types move to a state that is not populated by independent people and which has a closed primary.

Jim Shockley

Victor

Share this:

Filed Under: Opinion

Primary Sidebar

Search This Website

Search this website…

Local Info

  • Bitterroot Chamber of Commerce
  • Ravalli County
  • Ravalli County Economic Development Authority
  • City of Hamilton
  • Town of Stevensville
  • Town of Darby
  • Bitterroot Public Library
  • North Valley Public Library
  • Stevensville Community Foundation
  • Ravalli County Council on Aging
  • Bitterroot Producers Directory
  • Ravalli County Schools
  • Real Estate
  • Montana Works

Like us

Read our e-edition!

Montana Info

  • Montana Ski Report
  • Montana Fish, Wildlife, & Parks
  • National Parks in Montana
  • Montana Wildfires – INCIWEB
  • US Forest Service – Missoula
  • Firewise USA
  • Recreation.gov

Check Road Conditions

Road Conditions

Footer

Services

  • Place Classified Ad
  • Submit a Press Release
  • Letter to the Editor
  • Submit an Event
  • Subscribe
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Our location:

PO Box 133

115 W. 3rd Street
Stevensville, MT  59870
Phone: (406) 777-3928
Fax: (406) 777-4265

Archives – May 2011 to Present

Archives Prior to May 2011

Click here for archives prior to May 2011.

The Bitterroot Star Newspaper Co: ISSN 1050-8724 (Print) ISSN 2994-0273 (Online)
Copyright © 2026 · Bitterroot Star · Maintenance · Site by Linda Lancaster at Bitterroot Web Designs