by Sarah Glass
Soon after the 2027 Medicare enrollment period opened on October 15, Ravalli County patients of Bitterroot Health began receiving letters notifying them that Humana Medicare Advantage plans will no longer be “in-network” with the area’s largest healthcare provider next year. This news followed on the coattails of Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Montana (BCBSMT) and UnitedHealthcare (UH) announcing that Medicare Advantage plans in Ravalli County will not be renewed in 2027.
These decisions have caught many patients off guard, leaving them with limited time to find alternative coverage for the new year.
Char Jones is 74 years old. She lives in Hamilton and is a patient at Bitterroot Health enrolled in a Humana Medicare Advantage plan. Jones said she has had her plan for about nine years and really liked it. For her and her husband, the lower-premium, higher-deductible option worked. It has a drug plan built into it. Some plans provide vision and dental care, she said, as well as gym memberships. “It’s been a good program without a lot of money going out.”

Bitterroot Health CEO John Bishop spoke to the Bitterroot Valley Kiwanis about the county’s changing health insurance coverage landscape at BJ’s Restaurant in Hamilton on Nov. 11. Photo by Sarah Glass.
For Jones, facing the possibility of needing to find alternative healthcare coverage to stay in-network with Bitterroot Health has not been simple. “I myself have had some sleepless nights since I got that letter from the hospital,” she admitted. Still, she is thankful she has been able to secure an appointment with an insurance agent to discuss her options and finances.
As of early November, the Ravalli County Council on Aging, a nonprofit that helps seniors maintain independence, had all its appointment slots for health insurance counseling filled.
Hellman Insurance Agency in Missoula specializes in Medicare and Medicaid plan assistance. It has served Missoula and Ravalli County for about 20 years, said owner and broker Diane Hellman. The agency hosts free annual seminars in the Bitterroot Valley to help inform residents about their healthcare options. It was during one of these presentations that Hellman first heard about Bitterroot Health’s letter from panicked clients.
“I was doing some seminars there in the Bitterroot at the Bitterroot River Inn, and I had some clients say that they had heard that Bitterroot [Health] was leaving, and I thought, ‘well, that’s crazy,’” recounted Hellman. “I called my contact at Humana on the drive home, and she said that yes, they had gotten notice, and so they were trying to make contact with Bitterroot Health because there was no advance notice… It was just kind of out of the blue; at least that’s what Humana was telling me.”
Bitterroot Health CEO John Bishop recently gave a detailed presentation on what drove the hospital’s Medicare Advantage decision. The meeting was hosted by the Bitterroot Valley Kiwanis at BJ’s Restaurant in Hamilton on November 11. According to Bishop, Bitterroot Health has been tracking issues with Advantage plan payment delays and “downcoding” – a process by which insurers reimburse provider services at a lower level than what was performed – for years.
“Last year – 2025 – the shortfall created by Medicare Advantage versus traditional Medicare was $3.2 million, just in our hospital in one year,” he said.
Bishop described how, about a year ago, the hospital sent a letter with the Montana Hospital Association to delegates in Washington “explaining a lot of these problems” and “how it’s putting rural healthcare at risk.” About 11 months ago, it started trying to work with Humana directly to “settle out that cost difference report,” he said.
The issues remain unresolved.
“We’re at a point now where all we have left is to go through litigation,” said Bishop. “As a hospital, we haven’t sued anybody in my nine years here, not one person, and I don’t plan to start today.”
Bishop explained why Bitterroot Health is acting now to take Humana out-of-network rather than give patients more time to deal with the changing insurance landscape. Because BCBSMT and UH left their clients, he said, it created an opportunity for them to “migrate without consequence” and get onto a Medicare Supplement plan without dealing with insurance company cost/risk evaluations known as “underwriting.”
“If you are a United or Blue Cross patient, you have a special enrollment window to make a change. You don’t have to finalize that change until the end of that enrollment period. So, if you went to Humana already and decided, ‘wait, I don’t want to do that; I’d rather go back to Humana on a supplement rather than Advantage,’ you have until December 7 to make that change,” said Bishop.
He noted that Humana patients are facing the most difficult situation of all. They can switch plans and go through underwriting, remain with Bitterroot Health as an out-of-network patient or seek another provider. Regarding emergency medical care, all Advantage plans are considered to be “in-network,” Bishop emphasized. This does not include Bitterroot Health Urgent Care services.
While Bishop has heard rumblings of other insurers coming into Ravalli County, he said none have contacted the hospital yet.
The problem with transitioning, Hellman said, is that supplement plans “are not cheap” and “they are based on age.” At agency seminars, she says people are saying they can’t afford the prices.
“The problem is, there’s just shy of 2,900 people on Medicare Advantage with Humana in Ravalli County for 2026. This is before Blue Cross is pulling out… those people don’t have a guarantee issue into a supplement,” Hellman commented. “So, they are going to have to apply for a supplement and basically be able to say no to every underwriting question on that application.”
For Bitterroot Health patients who are going to new providers and receive discounted prescription drug prices through the 340B program, Hellman suggests they try to get their prescriptions re-upped for a year before transitioning. They can also check to see if their new provider is part of the program.
Financial assistance options are available for patients who wish to remain with Bitterroot Health, depending on their Federal Poverty Level. “If you are worried about your ability to pay those out-of-pocket costs or whether you can afford a supplemental plan… our financial assistance counselors are willing to meet with you to see if that program might apply to you,” said Bishop.
For patients trying to find a Medicare Supplement “Medigap” plan, Hellman Insurance Agency has free educational presentations scheduled for November 24 and December 1 at the Bitterroot River Inn in Hamilton. Details can be found at www.hellmaninsurance.com/events.
Leave a Reply