by David Haire, Florence
The following Ballot Issues (emphasis added) were soundly defeated in Ravalli County:
CI-132 (Ballot Issue #5)
Subject: A constitutional initiative that amends the Montana Constitution to require that judicial elections remain nonpartisan;
CI-133 (Ballot Issue #8)
Subject: The Montana constitution reserves to the people the powers of initiative and referendum. This act amends the constitution to protect this fundamental right from unjustified interference by the government.
I-194 (Ballot Issue #10)
Subject: An act, if passed, limits the powers of artificial persons to those powers necessary or convenient as provided by law.
The mail-in ballot package I received explained what the initiatives meant and had supporting and non-supporting statements from the pro- and anti- standpoints. From my perspective, the most interesting thing was that all of the anti-initiative statements (that is, to reject the issues) had one thing in common: Attorney and Representative Greg Overstreet from Ravalli County was a primary author.
How is it that Representative Overstreet’s efforts to thwart the will of the people in Ravalli County were supported by 61%, 57%, and 58% of Ravalli County voters, respectively? More than a suggestion, I believe we are witnessing the very definition of cognitive dissonance. This condition is described as a mental phenomenon in which people unknowingly or subconsciously hold fundamentally conflicting cognitions.
This is sort of like having a state constitution that guarantees “… the right to a clean and healthful environment …”, but then that same state’s Department of Environmental Quality is allowed to weaken environmental standards for air, land, and water quality protection. Oh yeah, yet looks like another form of cognitive discordance.
David Haire
Florence
Leave a Reply