• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Bitterroot Star

Bitterroot Valley's best source for local news!

  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Classifieds
    • Buildings
    • Farm & Garden
    • For Rent
    • For Sale
    • Free
    • Help Wanted
    • Real Estate
    • Sales/Auctions
    • Services
  • Legal Notices
  • Obituaries
  • Calendar
  • Services
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Place Classified Ad
    • Submit a Press Release
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
  • Subscribe

Doomed to repeat?

October 31, 2017 by Guest Post

 

Dr. Theodore Dalrymple’s (a pen name) analysis of the chaos going on in Great Britain goes like this:

“In modern welfare states, the struggle for subsistence has been abolished. There are large numbers of people who are devoid of either ambition or interest. They thus have nothing to fear, and nothing to hope.”

He has a succinct label for this problem – Learned Helplessness. Of course, his premise came out several years ago, and he subsequently moved to France. I don’t know whether this was a smart decision or not as we observe that country is having its problems, too!

What with ISIS spreading terror all over the world, MS-13 on the

East Coast, and the Charlottesville hooliganism (a woman died in the melee) and the fascist hanky-panky in California, let’s consider the idea that violence solves problems. Revolutions, at first, are always fun!

Unfortunately, that zeal morphs into events like the bloody French Revolution. In Galatians 4:18, the Apostle Paul liked zeal – “It is fine to be zealous, provided the purpose is good.”

The disillusion was great of naïve supporters of the Bourbons, first the French queen (remember she said, “If they can’t eat bread, let them eat cake!”) Madame Guillotine swallowed her up, followed by Royalists and the moderate Girondists, Camille Desmoulins, and Maximilien Robespierre – the architect of the chaos and thousands of others.

Are we learning anything from history’s harsh lessons?

Bruce King

Hamilton

Share this:

Filed Under: Opinion

Primary Sidebar

Search This Website

Search this website…

Local Info

  • Bitterroot Chamber of Commerce
  • Ravalli County
  • Ravalli County Economic Development Authority
  • City of Hamilton
  • Town of Stevensville
  • Town of Darby
  • Bitterroot Public Library
  • North Valley Public Library
  • Stevensville Community Foundation
  • Ravalli County Council on Aging
  • Bitterroot Producers Directory
  • Ravalli County Schools
  • Real Estate
  • Montana Works

Like us

Read our e-edition!

Montana Info

  • Montana Ski Report
  • Montana Fish, Wildlife, & Parks
  • National Parks in Montana
  • Montana Wildfires – INCIWEB
  • US Forest Service – Missoula
  • Firewise USA
  • Recreation.gov

Check Road Conditions

Road Conditions

Footer

Services

  • Place Classified Ad
  • Submit a Press Release
  • Letter to the Editor
  • Submit an Event
  • Subscribe
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Our location:

PO Box 133

115 W. 3rd Street
Stevensville, MT  59870
Phone: (406) 777-3928
Fax: (406) 777-4265

Archives – May 2011 to Present

Archives Prior to May 2011

Click here for archives prior to May 2011.

The Bitterroot Star Newspaper Co: ISSN 1050-8724 (Print) ISSN 2994-0273 (Online)
Copyright © 2026 · Bitterroot Star · Maintenance · Site by Linda Lancaster at Bitterroot Web Designs